Since March 2021 · 1310 reportsEvery claim on the record · every date is original
dailypol.The record

Disasters & Accidents · The Record

Fire chief says six cars and one engine derailed after train struck dump truck at Cape Girardeau County quarry

The crash report quoted by KFVS12 records crossarms, lights and a bell at a quarry where the fire chief described the railroad as private - and if the crossing there is a private grade crossing, GAO says projects at such crossings are not eligible for RHCP funding.

Level crossing, Ayawaso West (P1090897)
“Level crossing, Ayawaso West (P1090897)”, by Matti Blume, via Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0

A dump truck came to a stop on railroad tracks at a quarry in Cape Girardeau County, Missouri, on Sunday morning and was struck in the side by a southbound train, according to a Missouri State Highway Patrol crash report as reported by KFVS12. The fire chief who responded said six cars and one engine derailed. The patrol described the truck's driver as a 37-year-old Cape Girardeau man; the fire chief said he was airlifted to a St. Louis trauma center with serious injuries.

Fruitland Fire Chief Ronald Kiplinger told KFVS12 that crews were sent to South Stone Quarry near 600 NE Quarry Drive around 9 a.m. on September 27, on a report that a large, oversized dump truck had collided with a BNSF train on a private railroad. Kiplinger said "six cars and one engine were derailed." The chief's phrase - a private railroad - describes the railroad rather than the crossing, and it is what this piece follows into the federal record, because the category does specific work there.

The mechanism reads the same in both local accounts, though neither capture identifies a single shared document, a report number or a date, and the two outlets differ even on whether the patrol's crash reporting is one report or several. KFVS12 reported the patrol's crash report placing the truck stationary on the tracks when the southbound BNSF train hit its side. WPSD Local 6 reported the crash report as describing the truck as travelling eastbound before it came to be stationary on the tracks and was struck by the oncoming train. On the crossing's equipment, KFVS12 quoted the patrol report as recording warning gear in use at the site: crossarms carrying lights, and a bell. That detail appears in the KFVS12 capture alone.

The driver went to St. Louis, and here the two outlets do not quite match. Kiplinger, per KFVS12, said the driver was airlifted to a St. Louis trauma center for treatment of serious injuries. WPSD, citing crash reports from the patrol, reported the destination as St. Louis University Hospital, while its own opening sentence describes it only as a local hospital. Neither capture names the driver, and neither carries any account of his condition after arrival.

The Fruitland Area Fire Protection District, in a Facebook post WPSD summarized, put its response at 9:01 a.m. and stated that a victim of the incident required extrication. Crews removed the patient from the vehicle, according to that post, with Jackson Fire Rescue and the East County Fire Protection District assisting and the Cape Girardeau Fire Department on standby. The post said no hazards were involved in the crash.

Fire appears in both accounts, briefly and with a small difference. The district's post said the fire tied to the incident had already gone out by itself before crews arrived; Kiplinger's account to KFVS12 has a fire burning when crews first got there and going out on its own. Kiplinger said there was no chemical spill, though a little coal did fall out of the cars.

Cause is open. KFVS12 reported that the patrol and the railroad company are investigating, and the fire district's post, as WPSD carried it, said the cause and circumstances remain under investigation. Nothing in the captured passages assigns fault to the driver, the railroad or the quarry, and this piece does not either.

A Government Accountability Office report carrying the number GAO-25-107115, presented in the captured text as a review of railway-highway crossings and of federal technical assistance about pedestrian projects related to trespassing, draws the federal funding boundary in one sentence about its own method: "We did not include private grade crossings in our review, because projects at these crossings are not eligible for RHCP funding." The same passages give the size of the program the report calls RHCP - for fiscal years 2022 through 2026, GAO states, FHWA is required by statute to set aside at least $245 million a year for it. They also give the scale it works against: in 2023 there were nearly 1,900 crashes at railway-highway grade crossings, the places where railroad tracks and roads or pedestrian walkways intersect at the same level.

A second GAO report supplies the casualty picture and one finding that cuts against the intuitive reading of warning hardware. The capture carries it under the title "Grade-Crossing Safety: DOT Should Evaluate Whether Program Provides States Flexibility to Address Ongoing Challenges"; the number GAO-19-80 comes from the URL of the page captured, not from the captured text, and the passages carry no publication date. "Crashes at highway-rail grade crossings are one of the leading causes of railroad-related deaths," that report states. Citing FRA data, it counts more than 2,100 crashes in 2017 resulting in 273 fatalities. The captured passages add, without an attribution of their own, that since 2009 there have been about 250 fatalities annually, almost one percent of total highway fatalities. They record FHWA's report that the program that report examines - which the captured passages never name, so it cannot be read here as the RHCP of GAO-25-107115 - has cut fatalities by about 74 percent since 1975, and FRA's expectation that crashes will grow in future, partly on an anticipated increase in rail and highway traffic. They also state that more than 70 percent of the fatal crashes in 2017 happened at grade crossings with gates.

Read together, the fire chief's account and the two GAO reports point at a conditional this desk can state and nobody in the captured coverage does. Kiplinger's phrase describes the railroad, not the crossing, and no captured passage defines a private grade crossing or says that a crossing on a privately owned railroad is one. If the crossing where the truck stopped is a private grade crossing in the sense GAO uses, then GAO's own sentence settles two things about it: projects there are not eligible for the RHCP funding, and GAO left such crossings out of its review for that reason. The captures do not establish that it is. Separately, the presence of crossarms, lights and a bell is not on its own a sign of a safe location, since most of the fatal crashes counted for 2017 occurred at crossings with gates - and that reading holds only so far as crossarms of the kind the patrol report describes are gates in GAO's sense, which the captured passages do not say.

The limits on that reading matter as much as the reading. GAO states a general eligibility rule; it makes no finding about South Stone Quarry, and none of the captured passages carries a federal inventory entry, a classification or a funding record for this crossing. The word private here is the fire chief's on-scene description as one outlet reported it, not a determination by any federal agency.

What a reader can check next sits with the two open inquiries: the patrol's and the railroad's, both described as continuing in the captured reports. A completed crash report would settle the truck's approach, the state of the warning devices at the moment of impact, and the driver's condition. The statutory set-aside GAO describes is stated for fiscal years 2022 through 2026, and the captured passages carry no figure for any year outside that span. And FRA's expectation of more crashes, as the grade-crossing safety report records it, is checkable in the FRA data that report cites.